Anti-bacterial soaps and hand sanitizers: helpful or harmful?

84

By ninja87

One of the most common ways in which bacteria is spread is via sneezing
One of the most common ways in which bacteria is spread is via sneezing
There more than you think lurking on that mouse your holding and the keyboard your typing on
There more than you think lurking on that mouse your holding and the keyboard your typing on
Again, another number 1 transmission factor is physical contact
Again, another number 1 transmission factor is physical contact
"Color-enhanced scanning electron micrograph showing Salmonella typhimurium (red) invading cultured human cells" - Wikipeida
"Color-enhanced scanning electron micrograph showing Salmonella typhimurium (red) invading cultured human cells" - Wikipeida
Not quite sure what this one is... but I sure don't like the thought of it being in or on me!
Not quite sure what this one is... but I sure don't like the thought of it being in or on me!
"Escherichia coli cells magnified 25,000 times" - Wikipedia
"Escherichia coli cells magnified 25,000 times" - Wikipedia
"Diagram of the cellular structure of a typical bacterial cell" - Wikipedia
"Diagram of the cellular structure of a typical bacterial cell" - Wikipedia

I chose to answer this request as I feel as though it's something I can answer from both a personal and (loosely) professional prospective.

A few weeks ago I noticed a lot of people in my workplace coughing, sneezing and sniffling, it got to the point where it was all I could hear. It quickly became apparent that there was some kind of bug going around, the most likely culprit being the common cold.

Anyway, being a bit of a hypochondriac I quickly started reading into how our immune system works, "common cold" prevention techniques and how the virus itself works.

What I concluded from my probably highly neurotic time spent researching online anyway was that the best prevention methods are to avoid coming into contact with anyone or anything that carry the bacteria. You're probably thinking "well surely, isn't that obvious!", but I've been quite lucky growing up in that I haven't been that prone to catching what everyone around me has (so subsequently I've never paid that much attention). For sometime I thought I was superhuman, with a kickass immune system actually. That theory quickly died off when I did have a cold sometime last year though.

So I found out that the best ways to keep this "plague", as I started calling it from getting the best of me I started taking action! To start with I started drinking considerably more water, and breathed in only through my nose; as apparently there is more mucus within your nose lining, compared to our mouths, which helps trap and expel the bacteria before it manages to get into our bodies.

By this point you may also be thinking, "Wait, isn't this hub meant to be about hand sanitizers? All this crazed fool has talked about so far is his irrational fear of bacteria!" - Fear not though! (Good on you if you've gotten this far too by the way) as this is where the hand sanitizer comes in (see it was all just a build up! I was just creating some atmosphere, not quite sure what kind of atmosphere you require when talking about hand sanitizer though...)

I had noticed a slight ritual in a colleague of mine, that before eating her lunch she would always run her hands in this gel that I had never even seen or heard of before! This of course, was non other than anti-bacterial gel, "Cuticura Original" to be exact.

Initially I was a little dubious of trying this gel, as even though I adore the thought that 99.99% of those little badies will be eliminated within 15 seconds of application, I really don't like the sticky, uncomfortable feeling left on my hands after most creams, gels etc do. This one however, didn't so, in - my eyes, its perfection!

I started using it a great deal of the time, along with drinking more water, an breathing through my nose an I am yet to catch what looks like has been a passing "bug"!

So, now to hear what the professionals have to say.

I have been doing a bit of research on this as I always like to know everything there is to know about anything new I start using be it new medications, body washes etc.

The general impression I gathered from reading various studies and professional opinions is that anti bacterial gels are an excellent idea, and will become more central to our day to day lives. As currently they're are generally only found in hospitals or toilets, in the future companies may encourage their employees to use them, as according to one study the amount of bacteria found on general desk top equipment equals that to the average office toilet!

The only factor that has been brought to light is that such gels have to be at least 60% alcohol, as this is the ingredient that kills the bacteria. Any less then this and the gel may even help mobilise the bacteria, increasing the chance of infection.

So, in conclusion, hand sanitizers seem to have the thumbs up from both a consumer and the professionals - smiles all round!

Check out my other travels on Dan in Australia: Australia Travel Blog

Evolving Hand Sanitisers?...

Comments

solarshingles profile image

solarshingles 3 years ago

I think, that moderation is good at just anything in our life. We simply need to allow our body to get used to our every day environment and to all microorganisms around us. Our immune system is just marvelous in dealing with all constant threats which are entering our body. There is also other part of the equation we need to keep in mind: stronger anti-bacterial chemicals we are constantly creating, are causing stronger and more resistant new mutated bacterias and viruses. Mother nature is just amazing in adaptive abilities of all life forms to new surrounding conditions. We simply cannot change that race, which is there for many billion years.

Juliet Christie profile image

Juliet Christie 3 years ago

Well that is something to try out. Do much alcohol can dry out the skin so hand washing should not be entirely left out. I think one one the most unsanitary practice is the shaking of hands.

Terence Yap 2 years ago

The benefits of using Eco Verde "EVIDA" Hand Sanitizer

- Kills 99.9993% of germs which is cleaner than washing hands with water and soap (99.9).

- Forms a protective coating which keep hands free of bacteria for more than 2 hours.

- Extremely safe and non toxic, and therefore suitable for children to use.

- Non alcohol based so it does not dry your skin and is non flammable.

- Specially formulated to keep hands soft and does not cause irritation.

Why Alcohol-based Hand Sanitizers is not recommended ?

Don’t get me wrong, Alcohol is a very good killer of Bacteria, but it will only be on your skin for 7 – 10 seconds, before vaporising.

And while it is there, Alcohol removes the lipids, which is one of our bodies' natural defenses against bacteria.

Repeated usage of alcohol actually increases skin bacteria five hours later, compared with using nothing at all.

It will dry our skin and can cause painful irritations, that last for days.

Alcohol-based hand sanitizers does not offer enough protection against Norovirus and other germs (only 99.999%).

To kill 99.999% of the germs, Eco Verde's "EVIDA" Foaming Hand Sanitizers uses an active ingredient, benzalkonium chloride, an alcohol-free antimicrobial compound which has been widely used in hospitals for more than 60 years in surface cleaners, sterilizing agents, leave-on FDA Monograph and anti-bacterial skin treatments.

EVIDA Hand Sanitizer is very efficient at reducing a broad range of pathogenic bacteria on the skin in as little as 15 seconds such as:

Campylobacter jejuni

Candida albicans

Clostridium difficile (C-Diff)

Escherichi coli (E Coli)

Escherichia coli O157:H7

Klebsiella pneumonia

Listeria monocytogenes

Norovirus Feline

Norovirus Murine

Salmonella choleraesuis serotype enteritidis

Salmonella choleraesuis serotype paratyphi

Salmonella choleraesuis serotype pullorum

Salmonella choleraesuis serotype typhimurium

Salmonella typhi

Xanthomonas axonopodis (Citrus Canker)

Shigella dysenteriae

Shigella flexneri

Shigella sonnei

Staphylococcus aureus

Staphylococcus epidermidis

Staphylococcus aureus Methicillin resistant (MRSA)(Super Bugs)

Streptococcus pneumonia

Streptococcus pyogenes

Vibro cholera

Enterococus fascalis Vancomycin Resistant (VRE)

Yersinia enterocolitica

Eco Verde Products are made in the USA.

Efficiency tested by Singapore Test Services,

Test Report Number: 8250-1208-02597/M0460(B)-1

Terence Yap

terence@eco-verde.asia write to me and discuss hygiene.

+65 8186 7168

by the way, The green coloured bacterium is the Geobacter metallireducens

lilsnwbunny 2 years ago

if you have gross germs on your hands you can get really sick so wash your hands

CUMAR SAMAALE 2 weeks ago

HOW FEEL THE BECTERIA

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working